Sprinkler contractors, facilities managers, and their technical advisors sometimes have to deal with corrosion inside pressurized, water-based, metal fire sprinkler piping systems.
Sprinkler contractors, facilities managers, and their technical advisors sometimes have to deal with corrosion inside pressurized, water-based, metal fire sprinkler piping systems. Examples of such corrosion are discussed and illustrated in an article published by Clarke in the Winter 2001 issue of Fire Protection Engineering.1 Clarke observed that corrosion causes pinhole leaks as well as insoluble corrosion residue buildup ("obstructive growth") that increases pipe friction losses. Corrosion deterioration was attributed to microorganisms in water, i.e., to microbiologically influenced corrosion (MIC).
Clarke referred to an earlier nationwide (U.S.) survey of pinhole leaks in metal fire sprinkler piping reported by Bsharat in 1998.2 Bsharat also attributed pinholes and obstructive growth to MIC. Among measures that Bsharat and Clarke described to overcome MIC is chemical treatment of water in fire sprinkler piping with disinfectants (biocides) such as "chlorine, iodine, hydrogen peroxide, and ozone"2 and "ammonium compounds, organo-sulfur compounds, bromines, carbamates, isothiothiaza-lone,..."1 These chemicals destroy bacteria and their habitats, i.e., biofilms. Both Bsharat and Clarke also suggested cleansing obstructive growth inside piping via flushing and rinsing with chemically treated water. Clarke noted that the most critical step in MIC mitigation is selection of a qualified corrosion control consultant.
As Clarke pointed out, the National Fire Codes address MIC with a statement requiring that water supplies be tested and treated if the water is known to have contributed to MIC in fire sprinkler piping.3
This article is based on a review of the engineering and scientific literature pertaining to biological and nonbiological metal corrosion processes. The objective of the review was to establish a fundamental understanding of the corrosion of fire sprinkler piping in such facilities as office buildings, hotels, warehouses, shopping centers, and public buildings. Findings of this review indicate that several metal corrosion processes besides MIC can occur inside pressurized, water-based, metal fire sprinkler piping. For example, Notarianni and Jackson in 19944 pointed out that oxygen alone causes harmful corrosion that results in pits and sedimentation. Speller in 19515 compared corrosion in hot-water heating systems and automatic fire extinguisher systems due to dissolved gases such as oxygen. The scientific literature of electrochemistry is rich with examples of corrosion processes other than MIC that can deteriorate metals. For example, "oxygen corrosion" is a nonbiological process that can corrode certain metals. Moreover, "acid-oxygen corrosion" is a nonbiological process that can corrode certain metals even faster than oxygen corrosion. This article discusses these and other nonbiological corrosion processes that are spontaneous under the conditions of temperature and pressure that prevail in pressurized, water-based, metal fire sprinkler piping systems.
Nonbiological corrosion processes always generate dissolved metal as the initial corrosion product. Ongoing localized dissolving eventually produces pits and sometimes pinhole leaks. Moreover, dissolved metal (i.e., metal ions) can react speedily with certain chemical species that are dissolved in most waters to produce insoluble corrosion residues such as oxides, hydroxides, and carbonates. These residues produce obstructive growth that adheres to the interior pipe wall and increases pipe friction losses. The increase is especially significant in small-diameter pipe.
As regards MIC, review of the literature of microbiology did not identify any microorganisms that can attack directly an elemental metal or an alloy and cause it to dissolve, i.e., to release metal ions into the water. This point is relevant to corrosion control strategies. For example, the literature indicates that metal ions from some of the nonbiological corrosion processes can serve as nutrients for certain microorganisms. Consequently, microorganisms such as bacteria must compete for metal ions with various chemical species in water that produce insoluble corrosion residues. Because it is not established that microorganisms dominate this competition, MIC is not an assured sole explanation of corrosion deterioration of pressurized, water-based, metal fire sprinkler piping. In fact, physical evidence is needed to make MIC even a partial explanation of such corrosion deterioration. For example, persuasive evidence would be a finding of bacteria that use dissolved pipe metal (metal ions) for nutrients embedded in insoluble corrosion residues and inside pinholes. Scanning electron microscope inspection at magnifications of 10,000 to 20,000 times is a reasonable approach to search for such evidence.
In summary, this article presents many findings of a literature survey about nonbiological and biological corrosion processes that can deteriorate pressurized, water-filled, low-carbon steel pipe that is used for fire sprinkler piping.3 Such pipe is composed of about 98 percent iron. The twofold purpose of this article is to describe several iron-water corrosion processes that can contribute to producing pinhole leaks and obstructive growth in low-carbon steel piping systems, and to suggest several corrosion-control measures.
Corrosion processes involve paired, mutually dependent electrochemical reactions between metal and certain reactive chemical species dissolved in ordinary fresh water. 6, 7, 8, 9 Reactions occur at the metal-water interface and tend to speed up with increasing temperature. Concentrations of individual corrosive chemical species in fresh water charged into fire sprinkler piping systems from public water supplies usually range from 1 to 200 milligrams per liter. For example, the solubility of oxygen in water is about 8 milligrams per liter at 60F and atmospheric pressure. 10 Spontaneous electric charge transfer occurs at the atomic scale of dimensions during corrosion reactions, e.g., dissolved oxygen receives electrons from iron metal during the process of oxygen corrosion of low-carbon steel pipe. 2 External electrical factors are not likely to play a role in corrosion processes if the piping system is electrically grounded.
Corrosion reactions dissolve ("leach") metal. Following electron transfer, metal particles with positive electrical charge ("ions") are expelled into the water. Wasting of metal one particle at a time produces pits, craters, and sometimes penetrations during time spans ranging from months to years. Corrosion processes tend to localize in crevices and underneath aggregations of insoluble substances. 11 Insoluble substances that might be found inside steel fire sprinkler piping systems include scale from hard water of high carbonate or bicarbonate alkalinity, sediments, chips and filings from drilling and sawing during fabrication, and corrosion residues. Several corrosion processes that can occur inside water-based, metal fire sprinkler piping are described below. Each process can proceed independently of any other, provided the necessary chemical ingredients are available and that physical conditions are suitable. Each corrosion process is described in more detail elsewhere.12
- Oxygen corrosion is due to oxygen dissolved in water reacting with metals.11 Discussions of oxygen corrosion often use rusting of iron by dissolved oxygen as an example of one of many possible metal-water corrosion processes.2, Figure 1 illustrates orange-brown rust ("hydrated ferric iron oxide") that forms spontaneously on low-carbon steel pipe and cast-iron fittings exposed to outdoor conditions. Oxygen dissolved in atmospheric moisture fuels such rusting. The electrochemical reactions causing rust formation also can occur inside pressurized, water-based, low-carbon steel fire sprinkler piping if the water contains dissolved oxygen.
- Acid corrosion is caused by hydrogen ions from dissolved acids reacting with metals.11 Ordinary fresh water usually is considered acidic when the chemical characteristic, "pH," is below the neutral pH value of 7. However, water chemists consider waters to be acidic 13 only when pH drops below the "M alkalinity endpoint" of 4.4.14 This apparent contradiction in the definition of acidic water is due to alkalinity that arises from hydrolysis associated with dissolved bicarbonates and several other chemical species.15 The pH of most public water supplies charged into fire sprinkler piping systems ranges between 7.3 and 8.4,14 so it is not likely that acidified water is charged into a piping system. However, concentrations of acidified water can arise spontaneously in certain localities inside a closed piping system via hydrolysis of hydrated metal ions.11, 16, 17, 18 Localities that favor spontaneous acidification include crevices and regions underneath aggregations of insoluble substances. 11 Trace concentrations of chloride ions and sulfate ions play a role in hydrolysis. 11,12 Acidified water also can be generated by the metabolism of acid-producing bacteria or sulfate-reducing bacteria living in biofilms that might be growing inside a piping system. 11,
- Acid-oxygen corrosion occurs in oxygenated acid solutions and is due to an electrochemical reaction in which hydrogen ions and dissolved oxygen team up to waste metal.20 Acid-oxygen corrosion in iron-water systems usually is a speedier process than either oxygen corrosion or acid corrosion acting alone.
- Hypochlorite corrosion occurs when certain chlorine-based disinfectants found in most public water supplies react with metal.14 Concentration of disinfectants usually ranges from 1 to 4 milligrams per liter of "free available chlorine." Chlorine and hypochlorite disinfectants hydrolyze water to produce biocidal hypochlorous acid molecules in acidified water and hypochlorite ions otherwise. Both of these chemical species can corrode low-carbon steel and most other structural metals.
- Microbiologically Influenced Corrosion (MIC) is another segment of the corrosion world and is traceable to certain microorganisms.11,14 For example, bacteria are a category of single-cell microorganisms that frequently participate in biologically mediated corrosion. They live in aggregations of wet, viscous, gelatinous substances called biofilms. Several bacterial species and many millions of miniscule creatures might thrive communally in a biofilm 19 where chemical and physical conditions are favorable. Biofilms trap organic matter and certain dissolved chemical species that serve as nutrients for bacteria. 11, 15 The metabolic processes of certain bacteria produce waste products such as organic acids that are the source of hydrogen ions that can cause acid corrosion of most metals. 11 Interestingly, bacterial metabolism is understood in terms of electrochemical reactions, as are the foregoing metal-water corrosion processes. 21
Pinhole leaks usually spray with no forewarning and cause water damage to the surroundings. Figure 2 illustrates a pinhole leak that sprayed, whereas Figure 3 shows a seeping pinhole leak on the verge of spraying. Remedy usually involves immediately sealing pinhole leaks with temporary encirclement sleeves and replacing degraded sections of piping.
Pinhole leaks are caused by one or more ongoing electrochemical corrosion processes that usually are localized in crevices or underneath aggregations of insoluble substances.11 A spraying pinhole leak might take several months or several years to develop, depending on pipe wall thickness, ambient temperature, and availability of chemical ingredients for corrosion reactions. Reactions are focused so precisely that the process could be called chemical drilling.
Outbreaks of several pinhole leaks nearby one another in an older or a thin-wall piping system sometimes occur when fresh supplies of water are introduced frequently into a completely drained piping system, e.g., during construction to expand or rehabilitate a piping system that has been in service for several years. Introduction of water replenishes the reactive chemical ingredients that dissolve ("leach") metal from the interior pipe wall. Air that is not vented during charging can become trapped and compressed at high elevations. The increased solubility of oxygen in water at typical gage pressures of 50 to 160 pounds per square inch (340 to 1,100 kPa) in a fire sprinkler piping system provides ample dissolved oxygen to fuel oxygen corrosion in such localities. Oxygen corrosion is a likely contributor to the formation of pinhole leaks.
INSOLUBLE CORROSION RESIDUES
Ongoing corrosion reactions cause buildup of insoluble corrosion residues on the interior pipe wall over months and years, gradually increasing pipe friction losses. Residues form when metal ions react spontaneously with certain other dissolved chemical species, including oxygen. Figure 4 illustrates dried-out residues in a steel pipe section long after removal from a fire sprinkler piping system. These residues are probably iron compounds, e.g., oxides, hydroxides, and carbonates. 17, 22 Regions where residues have built up on the interior pipe wall can be located, and wall thickness can be measured, by applying non-destructive techniques such as ultrasound to the exterior pipe surface. 23 Residue thickness also can be measured using ultrasound. 24 Residues can be flushed from a piping system using weakly acidified solutions that disrupt and carry away most insoluble aggregations that build up on the interior pipe wall. Cleansing with solutions that neutralize acidity follows such flushing. 25 More detail about the causes of buildup and clearing away of insoluble aggregations appears elsewhere. 12
The Friction Loss Formula 3 for fire sprinkler piping indicates that frictional resistance increases exponentially with a linear decrease in actual internal diameter. Consequently, the gradual buildup of obstructive growth due to insoluble corrosion residues such as those shown in Figure 4 can increase pipe friction losses. Dramatic increases can occur in small-diameter pipe because pipe friction losses vary inversely with diameter (d), i.e., with d -4.87. For example, analysis using the Friction Loss Formula shows that pipe friction doubles if internal diameter decreases from 2.00 to 1.75 inches (50 to 44 mm); friction quadruples if internal diameter decreases from 1.00 to 0.75 inches (25 to 19 mm). Although the Friction Loss Formula does not apply accurately to a nonuniform buildup of obstructive growth like that in Figure 4, it is clear that gradual buildup increases pipe friction losses to a value greater than that calculated by designers from the actual internal diameter of uncorroded pipe.
The Friction Loss Formula3 also indicates that pipe friction losses depend on the surface texture of the interior pipe wall, which is represented quantitatively by the friction loss coefficient, C. Pipe friction losses are proportional to 1/C 1.85. "C" becomes smaller as the surface texture roughens. Consequently, pipe friction losses can increase significantly as obstructive growth due to insoluble corrosion residues gradually build up and roughen the interior pipe wall.
Figure 5 shows wet, black, sulfurous-smelling residues found inside a freshly removed steel pipe section. These residues probably contain the insoluble black oxide of iron, magnetite, which forms when dissolved oxygen is scarce. 15 The sulfurous odor suggests that these residues probably also contain sulfide ions (low pH) or bisulfide ions (high pH). These ions form when sulfate ions present in the water are used by sulfate-reducing bacteria as terminal electron acceptors. 15, 26 The residues in Figure 5 probably contain some insoluble black ferrous iron sulfides that are produced by the reaction between dissolved iron and sulfide ions.
The following measures can minimize iron-water corrosion inside pressurized, water-based, low-carbon steel fire sprinkler piping. These measures are discussed more fully elsewhere.12
- Reducing the frequency of filling a piping system and venting trapped air tend to minimize oxygen corrosion.
- Inspecting a piping system externally using nondestructive evaluation techniques such as ultrasound can locate regions where insoluble substances have built up on the interior pipe wall and also regions where corrosion has reduced pipe wall thickness to unacceptable values.
- Flushing a piping system with a solution that disrupts and carries away insoluble aggregations and biofilms that build up on the interior pipe wall minimizes underdeposit corrosion that causes pits, craters, and sometimes penetrations. Shaking out chips and filings from drilling and sawing during fabrication also minimizes underdeposit corrosion.
- Maintaining pH in the range 8.3 to 8.5 so that water cannot become acidified via hydrolysis of hydrated metal ions minimizes acid corrosion.
- Chemically treating water to minimize chloride and sulfate concentrations minimizes acidification via hydrolysis of hydrated metal ions. Minimizing sulfate concentration also minimizes acidification due to metabolism of sulfate-reducing bacteria.
- Minimizing organic matter in input water and lubricants on interior pipe surfaces reduces the metabolic activity of bacteria that produce acids upon using organic matter for nutrients, e.g., acid-producing bacteria such as Clostridia and Thiobacillus, as well as sulfate-reducing bacteria.
- Providing continuous, adherent, nonporous coatings on a metal surface can block electrochemical reactions between corrosive chemical species dissolved in water and metal.
- Providing a corrosion allowance, i.e., more metal thickness than is needed to support structural loads, increases the service time before corrosion causes undesirable consequences.
- Keeping an operations log provides a database that can help sprinkler contractors, facilities managers, and their technical advisors evaluate corrosion durability and reliability of fire sprinkler piping systems. A log might record renovations and rehabilitations, changes in water chemistry, results of nondestructive inspections, and general maintenance procedures.
Craftspeople, managers of fire sprinkler contractors, and facilities managers provided perspective on many of the practical aspects of fire sprinkler piping system fabrication and operation mentioned in this paper. Ms. Brenda Little provided tutorial information about biofilms and bacteria that participate in biologically mediated corrosion. Mr. Myron Shenkiryk provided several technical discussions and references to the literature about corrosion of fire sprinkler piping. Mr. Roland Huggins assisted with references to NFPA 13 and to the literature about corrosion of fire sprinkler piping. Mr. Mike Gorman provided an opportunity to photograph the pipe section shown in Figure 4. The management of Converse Consultants/Las Vegas, Nevada, provided a wide range of office facilities for manuscript preparation.
Bruce Christ is with Converse Consultants.
- Clarke, B.H., Microbiologically Influenced Corrosion in Fire Sprinkler Systems, Fire Protection Engineering, Issue No. 9, Winter 2001, pp. 14-22.
- Bsharat, T.K., Detection, Treatment, and Prevention of Microbiologically Influenced Corrosion in Water-Based Fire Protection Systems, Technical Report of the National Fire Sprinkler Association, Inc, 4 Robin Hill Corporate Park, Patterson, New York, June 1998.
- NFPA 13, Standard for the Installation of Sprinkler Systems, National Fire Protection Association, Batterymarch Park, Quincy, MA, 2002.
- Notarianni, K., and Jackson, M.A., Material Degradation Corrosion, Scale Build-Up, and Sedimentation/Steel, Comparison of Fire Sprinkler Piping Materials: Steel, Copper, Chlorinated Polyvinyl Chloride, and Polybutylene, in Residential and Light Hazard Installations, NISTR 5339, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD, June 1994.
- Speller, F.N., Corrosion Causes and Prevention, 3rd Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc., New York, 1951.
- Evans, U.R., Electrochemical Corrosion, Chapter IV, The Corrosion and Oxidation of Metals: Scientific Principals and Practical Applications, Edward Arnold Ltd., London, 1960.
- Pourbaix, M., Introduction to Corrosion, Lectures on Electrochemical Corrosion, Plenum Press, New York, 1973.
- Scully, J.C., Aqueous Corrosion, The Fundamentals of Corrosion, 3rd Edition, Pergamon Press, New York, 1990.
- Oxtoby, D.W., Gillis, H.P., and Nachtrieb, N.H., Electrochemistry/Corrosion and Its Prevention, Principles of Modern Chemistry, 4th Edition, Saunders College Publishing-Harcourt Brace College Publishers, New York, 1999.
- Staff of Betz Laboratories, Inc., Preboiler and Boiler Corrosion Control, Betz Handbook of Industrial Water Conditioning, 9th Edition, Betz Laboratories, Inc., Trevose, PA, 1991.
- Herro, H.M., and Port, R.D., The NALCO Guide to Cooling Water Systems Failure Analysis, McGraw-Hill, Inc., New York, 1993.
- Christ, B.W., Corrosion Control Inside Steel Fire Sprinkler Piping, accepted for publication in Journal of Fire Protection Engineering.
- Kotz, J.C., and Purcell, K.F., Oxidation-Reduction Reactions/Corrosion: An Example of Electron Transfer, Chemistry & Chemical Reactivity, Sanders College Publishing-Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Orlando, FL, 1987.
- Kremmer, F.N., Editor, The Nalco Water Handbook, 2nd Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, 1988.
- Drever, J.I., The Geochemistry of Natural Waters Surface and Groundwater Environments, 3rd Edition, Prentice-Hall Upper Saddle River, NJ, 1997.
- Vogel, A.I., The Theoretical Basis of Quantitative Inorganic Analysis The hydrolysis of salts, A Text-Book of Quantitative Inorganic Analysis, 3rd Edition, Longmans, Green & Co Ltd., Bungay, Suffolk, Great Britain, 1961.
- Brown, T.L., Lemay, H.E. Jr., and Bursten, B.E., Chemistry The Central Science, 6th Edition, Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1994, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
- Jones, L., and Atkins, P.W., Aqueous Equilibria/Ions as Acids and Bases, Chemistry Molecules, Matter, and Change, 4th Edition, W.H. Freeman and Company, New York, 2000.
- Little, B.J., Ray, R.I., and Pope, R.K., The Relationship Between Localized Corrosion aand The Biological Sulfur Cycle A Review, J. Corrosion, vol. 56/#4, 2000, pp. 433-443.
- Rieger, P.H., Corrosion Reaction of a Metal with Air-Saturated Water, Electrochemistry, 2nd Edition, Chapman and Hall, New York, 1994.
- Alcamo, I.E., Fundamentals of Microbiology, 6th Edition, Jones and Bartlett Publishers, Inc., Boston, MA, 2001.
- Talbot, D., and Talbot, J., Corrosion of Iron and Steels/Rusting, Corrosion Science and Technology, CRC Press LLC, Boca Raton, FL, 1998.
- Bray, D.E., and Stanley, R.K., Pipe Inspection/Subsection 8-9.4, Nondestructive Evaluation, A Tool in Design, Manufacturing, and Service, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 1997.
- Gorman, M., MICSCAN Services for FPS Inspection, Digital Wave Corporation, 11234A East Caley Avenue, Englewood, CO 80111 USA. (firstname.lastname@example.org)
- Mitigating MIC, Sprinkler Age, Sept. 1998, pp.26-27
- Stanier, R.Y., Ingraham, J.L., Wheelis, M.L., and Painter, P.R., The Microbial World, 5th Edition, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1986.